Matchmaker Santa

Lacey Chabert

Melanie "Skeeter" Hogan

Adam Mayfield

Dean Ford

Nikki Hahn

Young Melanie

Elizabeth Ann Bennett

Blaire

Florence Henderson

Peggy

Robert Pine

Jack Tisdale

John Ratzenberger

George

Lin Shaye

Debbie

Donovan Scott

Chris

Thad Luckinbill

Justin

Mary-Margaret Humes

Katherine

Victoria Gabrielle Platt

Donna

Lorna Scott

Sheriff Dispatcher

Nick Kiriazis

Bill Hogan

Erica Shaffer

Ruth Hogan

Carter Sand

Nicky

Kathy Byron

Waitress

Darby Jo Hart

Little girl