The Chosen One

Tim Curry

Lucifer

Chad Fifer

Lou Hanske

Chris Sarandon

Zebulon 'Zeb' Kirk (voice)

Danielle Fishel

Donna Goldstein (voice)

Lance Henriksen

Cardinal Fred (voice)

Laura Prepon

Rachel Cruz (voice)

Debra Wilson

Akia May (voice)

Traci Lords

Mrs. Sultry (voice)

Andreas Olavarria

Claude/Rabbi Sal/Doctor/Choir Boy(voice)

Scott MacDonell

Insurance Guy/Gary the Lawyer/Professor Zornoff/Evil Choir Boy(voice)

Michael Risley

Rick/Grifter/Azazel(voice)

Megan Austin Oberle

Ankh/Crossing girl #2(voice)

Andrew Leman

College Administrator/Mr. Gore/Demon Monk(voice)

Michael Ross

Drunk Mike/Sheik Abdul(voice) (as Mike Ross)

Amanda Winn Lee

Crossing Girl #1/Waitress(voice)

The Cockroach

Beelzebub(voice)