Natal Sangrento

Robert Brian Wilson

Billy at 18

Lilyan Chauvin

Mother Superior

Gilmer McCormick

Sister Margaret

Charles Dierkop

Killer Santa

Toni Nero

Pamela

Randy Stumpf

Andy

Linnea Quigley

Denise

Britt Leach

Mr. Sims

Leo Geter

Tommy

Amy Styvesant

Cindy

Jonathan Best

Billy at 5

Danny Wagner

Billy at 8

Tara Buckman

Mother (Ellie)

Geoff Hansen

Father (Jim)

Will Hare

Grandpa

Eric Hart

Mr. Levitt (Storekeeper)

A. Madeline Smith

Sister Ellen

H.E.D. Redford

Captain Richards

Max Robinson

Officer Barnes

Nancy Borgenicht

Mrs. Randall