On Broadway

Joey McIntyre

Jack O'Toole

Eliza Dushku

Lena Wilson

Mike O'Malley

Father Rolie O'Toole

Sean Lawlor

Martin O'Toole

Lance Greene

Billy O'Toole

Vincent Dowling

Augie Burke

Lucas Caleb Rooney

Neil Quinn

Peter Giles

Barry Cook

Kortney Adams

Sarah

Will Arnett

Tom

Amy Poehler

Farrah

Andrew Connolly

Uncle Pete

Jill Flint

Kate O'Toole

Jennifer Bertolon

Girl in Bar

Michael Bortone

Bar Patron

Robert Farrelly

Old Guy

Will Harris

Young Billy

Joel B. Hayden

Bar Patron

Brian Horan

Cab Driver

Georgia Lyman

Nancy