Death to Cupid

Mihaly 'Michu' Meszaros

Leprechaun

Carlos Alazraqui

The Tooth Fairy

Donovan Scott

Santa Claus

Curtis Hamilton

Craig

Nicole Dambro

Samantha

Michele Tobin

Charlie's Mother

Shad Roberts

Cupid

Joe Gonzales

Easter Bunny

Suzanne Cotsakos

Megan

Maisie Vargas

Jillian

Gavin Bryson Thompson

Young Charlie

Marley Gonzales

Marley

Matthew Swanson

Charlie