Baby in a Manger

Monica Knox

Alison

Michael Morrone

Brock

Caylin Turner

Traci

Stacey Bernstein

Chief Jane

Celestine Caravaggio

Yolanda

Brian Scott Carleton

Saul

Michelle Shaughnessy

Heather

Diana Chrisman

Candace

Mark Ettlinger

Barry

Madeline Leon

Nurse

Sloane Long

Angel

Katrina Parag

Church-Goer

Rebecca Perry

Jemma

Lily Ro

Jess

Callum Thompson

Han

Hugh Wilson

Father Mitchell

Naiya Novak

Child in Nativity pageant (uncredited)