Our First Christmas

Julie Warner

Cindy Baer-Noll

John Ratzenberger

Joe Noll

Dixie Carter

Evie Baer

Steven Eckholdt

Tom Baer-Noll

Cassi Thomson

Tory

Grace Caroline Currey

Lily

Maxim Knight

Jacob

Richard Riehle

Santa

Kat Graham

Assistant Bernie

Carly Bondar

Mean Girl #1

Lewis Smith

Pastor Brown

Chris LoPrete

Singer

Eric Seppala

Singer

Lisa Donahey

Singer

María Antonieta Vázquez

Barista

Brad Carr

Gardener (uncredited)